By Adam Pagnucco.
When you’re running for Montgomery County Democratic Central Committee, waaaaaay down the ballot, how do you campaign? Maybe you do this!
All posts by Adam Pagnucco
Balcombe’s Pitch to Upcounty
By Adam Pagnucco.
Whether they are right or wrong, MANY residents of Upcounty who communicate with your author feel that they are not treated as well by county government as their neighbors to the south. Council At-Large candidate Marilyn Balcombe, who lives in Germantown and is the CEO of the Gaithersburg-Germantown Chamber of Commerce, is tapping into that sentiment with this mailer sent to Upcounty residents. We think this is a smart move. With so many at-large candidates concentrating heavily on Downcounty’s Democratic Crescent and splitting the votes there, if Balcombe has Upcounty mostly to herself, she just might be able to fly under the radar to victory.
Campaign Finance Reports: Council Districts, May 2018
By Adam Pagnucco.
Today we look at fundraising by the Council District candidates. As with our prior posts on the County Executive and Council At-Large races, we start with a note on methodology. First, we calculate total raised and total spent across the entire cycle and not just over the course of one report period. Second, we separate self-funding from funds raised from others. Self-funding includes money from spouses. Third, for publicly financed candidates, we include public matching fund distributions that have been requested but not deposited in raised money and in the column entitled “Cash Balance With Requested Public Contributions.” That gives you a better idea of the true financial position of publicly financed campaigns.
Let’s start with the Council District 1 candidates.
Former Comptroller staffer Andrew Friedson is easily the fundraising leader. His total raised for the cycle ($333,081) exceeds any of the Council At-Large candidates and his cash on hand ($245,290) almost equals the cash on hand of the next three candidates combined ($251,205). Friedson has raised $159,257 from individuals in Bethesda, Chevy Chase, Glen Echo, Cabin John, Kensington, Potomac and Poolesville, which represents 48% of his take. That amount is not very different from the TOTAL fundraising from others reported by former Kensington Mayor Pete Fosselman ($174,996) and former Planning Board Member Meredith Wellington ($138,820). Of Friedson’s 1,074 contributions, 702 were for $150 or less.
The endorsement leader in District 1 is Delegate Ana Sol Gutierrez, who has the support of MCEA, Casa in Action, SEIU Locals 500 and 32BJ, Progressive Maryland and MCGEO. But Gutierrez’s main base of voters is Wheaton, which is not in the district, and she does not have a lot of money for mail. Friedson got a big boost when the Post endorsed him.
Reggie Oldak faces a cash crunch at the end because of her decision to participate in public financing. Unlike Friedson, Fosselman or Wellington, she can’t get big corporate or self-financed checks to catch up late and she has already received the maximum public matching funds available ($125,000). District 1 has by far more Democratic voters than any other district and past candidates, like incumbent Roger Berliner and former incumbent Howie Denis, raised comparable amounts to the at-large candidates. The next County Council should consider whether to adjust the matching funds cap to avoid handicapping future District 1 candidates who enroll in public financing.
Now let’s look at the Council District 3 candidates.
Incumbent Sidney Katz and challenger Ben Shnider have raised comparable amounts for the cycle. But Shnider’s burn rate has been much higher (partly driven by early mail) and Katz has more than twice his cash on hand.
Katz’s strength is not simply his incumbency but the fact that he has been a county or municipal elected official in the district longer than Shnider has been alive. That shows up in their fundraising. Katz is in public financing and recently announced that he will receive the maximum public matching funds contribution of $125,000. Of Shnider’s $199,454 total raised, just $14,639 (7%) came from individuals in Rockville, Gaithersburg, Washington Grove, Derwood and zip codes 20878 and 20906. That is a huge gap in starting indigenous support that Shnider has to close.
Here are the summaries for Council Districts 2, 4 and 5.
Council District 5 challenger Kevin Harris qualified for public matching funds so he can send mail against incumbent Tom Hucker. But we expect Hucker and his fellow council incumbents, Craig Rice and Nancy Navarro, to be reelected.
Josh Starr’s Picks
By Adam Pagnucco.
Josh Starr was Superintendent of MCPS from 2011 through 2015 and still lives in MoCo. He announced the candidates whom he supports on Facebook yesterday. Agree with Starr or not, his personal experience of working with state and county elected officials gives him a unique perspective on those running for office. With his permission, we reprint his post below.
*****
Very long post for my MoCo friends about my choices for the primaries, with notes/comments where I feel it’s appropriate. Please note that my choices and/or comments are based on my personal knowledge and experience with these folks, not any deep analysis of every statement/position/vote they’ve made. I definitely have biases.
Governor – Rich Madaleno; Baker would be my #2. When I was super, I found Rich to be one of the smartest, most thoughtful and most knowledgeable elected officials, esp. around budget. He was also one of the first Dems to push back against Hogan. Experienced, smart, progressive, would be a great governor. I’d also love to see an open member of the LGBTQ community elected governor, although that’s in no way the primary (pun intended) reason I’m supporting him.
Senator – Ben Cardin
Congress – Jamie Raskin, because he is, after all, The Jamie Raskin.
House of Delegates – 3 candidates:
Ariana Kelly – solid, speaks out on issues re: women, no reason for her not to continue in Annapolis.
Marc Korman – smart, thoughtful (in my LM class so I got to know him well), definitely a bright future.
Samir Paul – have had a few conversations with him, very sharp and we need more teachers in office.
County Executive (wherein I get a little snarky based on my experiences with many of these candidates). I also think the next CE might be a transitional leader, as we move from 12 years of Ike during an economic downturn towards a new vision that supports bold economic development with progressive politics.
I’m supporting Roger Berliner as I’ve always found him to be thoughtful, a really good listener/learner, consistent and progressive. I’ve always felt Roger tries to do the right thing in an inclusive and reasonable way and will work hard to bring people together around his vision.
A few comments on other CE candidates:
Blair – don’t know much about him, not a huge fan of business leaders assuming they can “save” public entities. I’m pretty agnostic.
Elrich – have always appreciated his progressive politics, always had a solid working relationship, sometimes I appreciate his willingness to take strong positions, sometimes I think they’re unforced errors; major concern is the big hill he’ll have to climb to convince a wide swath of the county that he can do economic development and enact a very progressive agenda.
Frick – there are some things I like about him, personally and professionally, but my experience with Roger Berliner outweighs any support for Frick.
Krasnow – don’t know her, but I hear good things, sounds like a solid choice.
Leventhal – based on personal/professional experience, I’m in the anyone-but-Leventhal camp. He doesn’t have the temperament or leadership skills to be CE, despite his sometimes-engaging personal style and progressive politics. Please, trust me on this one.
Council At-Large (4)
Gabe Albornoz – smart, engaging, thoughtful, has a very bright future; very supportive of kids and MCPS.
Hoan Dang – what I know, I like.
Will Jawando – he deserves a shot.
Hans Riemer – very education focused, solid on economy and progressive issues, always had a good working relationship, we need someone with experience and we need a degree of stability.
I am also in the anyone-but-Jill Ortman Fouse category, based on my experience with her as a board of education member while I was superintendent. Trust me.
Council – D1
Peter Fosselman – solid, good record in Kensington, deserves a shot at council.
BoE (always at the end of the ballot)
At-Large- Karla Silvestre, glad to see her running, great community leader, smart, thoughtful, will be a great BoE member.
D3 – Pat O’Neill, because she deserves a shot at the MD record for longest serving board member. On a serious note, she knows what the role of a board member is and provides an essential balance to other board members who think their job is to run the school system.
Looking for Michele Riley?
By Adam Pagnucco.
Would you like to find information on Council At-Large candidate Michele Riley? It’s easy. Just google one of her opponents.
Here’s an example. Let’s google fellow Council At-Large candidate Jill Ortman Fouse. See the first result? It’s Michele Riley’s website!
Let’s try this again and google Evan Glass. Wow, look at that! Michele Riley is the first result – again.
This works for a LOT of candidates. Let’s look up Hans Riemer, Hoan Dang, Ashwani Jain, Bill Conway, Marilyn Balcombe and Chris Wilhelm. You guessed it – the first result goes straight to Michele Riley.
See folks, this makes us wonder. We thought there were 33 Democrats running for Council At-Large. But what if that’s not true? What if only one person is running – Michele Riley!
It’s gonna be fun to have three special elections for the vacant at-large seats!
Self-Financing by MoCo Candidates
By Adam Pagnucco.
Businessman David Blair is being criticized for contributing $1.9 million to his campaign for County Executive. Council Member Marc Elrich, who is also running for Executive, told the Post, “David Blair can use money to commission polls and then create an image of himself based on poll results… We’ve had enough of buying images and elections.” That leads us to a question.
How have other big self-funders done in MoCo?
The chart below shows all MoCo-based candidates since the 2006 cycle who have self-financed at least $200,000 in an election.
Notice something? Only one of these folks won the election in which they self-financed at least $200,000: Congressman John Delaney.
Why did so many of these self-funders lose? Here are a few reasons applying to various races.
They ran in the wrong district.
This might be the biggest reason Total Wine co-owner David Trone lost the Congressional District 8 race despite massively outspending the winner, Jamie Raskin. The odds were long that CD8, with its dark blue enclaves of Takoma Park, Downtown Silver Spring, Kensington and Chevy Chase, would elect an alcohol salesman over a progressive, brainy and likeable college professor. Trone is much better off in CD6 with its more moderate voters. Similarly, real estate developer Josh Rales was no match for long-time Congressman Ben Cardin and former Congressman and NAACP President Kweisi Mfume in a statewide U.S. Senate primary.
They challenged an incumbent.
Dana Beyer and Amie Hoeber had uphill battles running against incumbents. Hoeber’s entry on this list deserves an asterisk because her committee funding did not include $3.8 million in outside spending by her husband.
Their message wasn’t great.
CD8 candidate Kathleen Matthews had a very generic message primarily targeted at women. District 20 House candidate Jonathan Shurberg’s message was indistinguishable from the other candidates in his race, some of whom were endorsed by Raskin and had the Apple Ballot. District 19 Senator Mike Lenett ran one of the most negative campaigns in MoCo history against the man who went on to defeat him, Delegate Roger Manno. Lenett’s Holocaust mailer was a killer mistake in the last days of the race.
They motivated the other side.
One veteran of Raskin’s congressional campaign told us, “We had a motto. You can outspend us but you will not outwork us!” Raskin’s door-knockers were dwarfed by Trone’s army but they were well-trained and highly motivated on his behalf. (This was evident by their comparative performances at your author’s door!) In the end, true-believer volunteers proved more effective than more numerous hirelings.
Delaney was the exception because he ran in a district that fit a center-left businessman, his main Democratic opponent took the election for granted, Republican incumbent Roscoe Bartlett was on his last legs and the district was gerrymandered to elect a Democrat. But there was more: in addition to his self-funding, Delaney raised $2 million in outside money during his first win in 2012. Most of his fundraising in his next two wins came from others and not himself.
There is no question that self-financing capacity is an advantage. But little in MoCo’s recent political history supports the notion that elections here can be outright bought. If Blair wins, it won’t just be because of money. As one of the wisest MoCo election observers we know told us recently, “You know, the reason self-funders usually lose is because they have a crappy (or no) message. But when they have a concise message… look out!”
Disclosure: The Executive candidate we are supporting, Roger Berliner, is not self-funding his race. If he did that, his wife would kill him!
District 20 Incumbents Team Up With Charkoudian
By Adam Pagnucco.
District 20 Senator Will Smith and Delegates David Moon and Jheanelle Wilkins have decided to team up with non-incumbent House candidate Lorig Charkoudian in the upcoming primary. Moon explained his decision to endorse his team on his Facebook page, writing specifically about Charkoudian, “I’ve also worked these last few years with Lorig on criminal justice reform and know she shares my commitment to driving down mass incarceration in Maryland. She used to live on my block in Takoma Park, and I’ve gotten to see her passion for justice issues up close.”
The decision to include a non-incumbent on the slate is reminiscent of 2014, when Senator Jamie Raskin and Delegate Sheila Hixson teamed up with new House candidates Moon and Smith. In that election, all four were on the Apple Ballot. That’s not true this time around as MCEA has supported Smith, Moon, Wilkins and second-time House candidate Darian Unger.
In addition to the incumbents, Charkoudian is supported by Casa in Action, the Laborers Union, MCGEO and NOW. Unger is supported by MCEA, SEIU Locals 500 and 32BJ and the Volunteer Fire Fighters. (Unger is himself a volunteer.) On May 22, Charkoudian reported a cash balance of $37,226 and Unger had $27,897.
Blair Responds to “Lies and Smears”
County Executive candidate David Blair has sent out the following blast email in response to criticism of his campaign over the last week.
*****
Friends,
As Michelle Obama said, “When they go low, we go high.” In the final days of a campaign some candidates start attacking with lies and smears. But our campaign isn’t going to do that.
We’re running a positive campaign focused on the important issues facing Montgomery County: growing our economy, fixing our broken infrastructure, improving our schools and making Montgomery County a place for everybody to live, work, start a business and raise a family.
And we need your help to spread the word about who I am and what I hope to accomplish for Montgomery County. Can you please share this video with friends, families, neighbors and colleagues?
David Blair is the Un Trump
Best wishes,
David
Kumar Barve’s Draft Notice, 1994
By Adam Pagnucco.
Once in a while, we’re going to post some lit from the past to show today’s newbies how it’s done. Below is Delegate Kumar Barve’s “draft notice” from 1994, in which the “drill instructor” says, “Delegate Barve will be instructing his troops in the delicate art of brew tasting, mingling around a pub, and having a general good time. So practice your push-ups and prepare yourself because DELEGATE BARVE WANTS YOU!”
That’s our kind of fundraiser!
