By Adam Pagnucco.
Correction: The numbers for Hoan Dang in this post are inaccurate. For updated numbers on Dang and a response by Marc Elrich, please visit our updated post.
One of the virtues of public campaign financing is the rapid release of financial reports for participating candidates. That’s right, folks – for this group of candidates, there is no need to wait until January to see fundraising numbers. That’s because when they qualify for public matching funds and request them from the state, their financial reports are released almost immediately. This is terrific for all data junkies like your author as well as inquiring minds among the readers!
Below is a summary for the five candidates who have applied to receive matching funds from the state. Bear in mind the following characteristics of the data. First, the number of qualifying contributors means the number of contributors who live in Montgomery County. Non-residents can contribute up to $150 each but the state will not authorize matching funds for them. Second, the individual contribution amounts are the basis on which the state determines how much in public matching funds will be released. Third, the date of cash balance is important because it varies depending on when the applications were sent in. That is unlike the regular reporting dates on which financial positions are summarized at the same time for all candidates. And fourth, for those candidates who have only filed once (which includes everyone except George Leventhal), the cash balances do not include public funds from the state. To estimate the cash positions of those candidates, the cash balance should be added to the public matching funds they requested.
What do we make of this?
1. Let’s start with the obvious: there are a lot of small checks out there! While many contributors are probably donating to more than one of these five campaigns, it’s not a stretch to say that close to a thousand people will have contributed by some point in the near future. It’s hard to make comparisons with the past without exquisitely detailed research to back it up (anyone want to pay us for that?) but our hunch is that this is a larger early donor pool than in prior cycles.
2. The big story here is Council At-Large candidate Hoan Dang. At-Large Council Members George Leventhal (who is running for Executive) and Hans Riemer (the only incumbent running for reelection) have a combined 22 years of representing the whole county. But Dang had more in-county contributors than either one of them! How does that happen? Dang ran for Delegate in District 19 in 2010. He was financially competitive, raising $103,418, but he finished fifth out of six candidates. There was no reason going into this race to believe that Dang would receive more grassroots financial support than Leventhal or Riemer. But so far, he has.
3. Dang is not the only story. Look at first-time candidate Bill Conway, who collected more private funds than Riemer primarily by having a larger average contribution. In most elections, challengers struggle to be financially competitive with incumbents. But the early performances of Conway and Dang relative to Riemer suggest that, at least among publicly-financed candidates, some or all of that gap may be closed. Our hunch is that a group of at-large candidates will all hit the public matching funds cap of $250,000 and therefore have similar budgets heading into mail season. The big question will then become how those totals compare to what candidates in the traditional system, like Marilyn Balcombe, Charlie Barkley, Ashwani Jain and Cherri Branson, will raise.
4. Where is Marc Elrich? The three-term at-large Council Member and Executive candidate announced that he had qualified for matching funds back in June at roughly the same time that Leventhal and Riemer said the same. Riemer followed up by filing for matching funds and Leventhal did it twice. Why hasn’t Elrich filed more than two months after his announcement? One suspects that the bewildering paperwork requirements of public financing are responsible for the delay, but political types are starting to chatter about it.
That’s all for now. Candidates, keep those reports coming in so your favorite blog has more material for the readers!